Choice
Choice is the range of different things from which a being can choose.
Choice is the range of different things from which a being can choose. The arrival at a choice may incorporate motivators and models. Freedom of choice is generally cherished, whereas a severely limited or artificially restricted choice can lead to discomfort with choosing, and possibly an unsatisfactory outcome. In contrast, a choice with excessively numerous options may lead to confusion, reduced satisfaction, regret of the alternatives not taken, and indifference in an unstructured existence; and the illusion that choosing an object or a course necessarily leads to the control of that object or course can cause psychological problems.
- field
- Decision theory, psychology, economics
- known_for
- Analysis of choice types, evaluability, and the paradox of choice
Lore & Background
One can distinguish four or five main types of decisions, although they can be expressed in different ways. Brian Tracy breaks them down into command decisions, delegated decisions, avoided decisions, no-brainer decisions, and collaborative decisions. Another way of looking at decisions focuses on the thought mechanism used: rational, intuitive, recognition-based, or combination. An alternate way to classify types of choices is to look at outcomes and the impacted entity, such as business, personal, or consumer choices. Politicians may choose to support or oppose options based on local, national, or international effects. As a moral principle, decisions should be made by those most affected by the decision, but this is not normally applied to persons in jail. One can distinguish between conscious and unconscious choice. Processes such as brainwashing or other influencing strategies may have the effect of having unconscious choice masquerade as conscious choice. Choices may lead to irreversible or to reversible outcomes; making irreversible choices may reduce choice overload.
Reader's Guide
When choosing between options one must make judgments about the quality of each option's attributes. Evaluability can cause preference reversals between joint and separate evaluations. For example, in a hiring decision, subjects in an experiment gave roughly the same starting salary to two candidates when viewed together, but paid the candidate with the high GPA substantially more when viewed separately. Several research studies have examined variations in individual behavior when confronted with a low versus high choice set size. The effect of choice set size on the probability of a purchase is unclear; in some cases large choice sets discourage choice, in others they encourage it or have no effect. There is some evidence that while greater choice has the potential to improve welfare, sometimes there is too much choice. A recent meta-analysis of the literature on choice overload calls such studies into question, finding that in many cases researchers have found no effect of choice set size on people's beliefs, feelings, and behavior. Overall, the effect of 'too many options' is minimal at best.
Did You Know?
- Brian Tracy breaks decisions into command, delegated, avoided, no-brainer, and collaborative types.
- Evaluability can cause preference reversals between joint and separate evaluations, as shown in a hiring experiment with GPA and KY program experience.
- A study found that individuals explicitly requested to choose from six as opposed to 24 sodas to reduce cognitive burden.
- A recent meta-analysis found that the effect of 'too many options' on people's beliefs, feelings, and behavior is minimal at best.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Choice as a philosophical tradition?
Choice refers to the full spectrum of options available to a being at any given moment, encompassing the motivators and models that shape how a decision is reached. It sits at the intersection of decision theory, psychology, and economics, where scholars examine how different types of options affect human behavior and satisfaction.
What is the paradox of choice?
The paradox of choice describes how an overwhelming number of available options can paradoxically reduce a person's satisfaction rather than increase it. Instead of feeling empowered, individuals may experience confusion, regret over the paths not taken, and a growing indifference toward an unstructured existence.
What happens when a being's options are severely restricted?
When choice is artificially narrowed, the resulting discomfort can make the decision-making process feel oppressive and lead to unsatisfactory outcomes. This stands in contrast to the general philosophical and cultural value placed on freedom of choice as a fundamental good.
What illusion does the tradition of Choice identify?
A central insight is that selecting a particular object or course of action does not automatically grant the chooser control over that object or path. This mistaken assumption of mastery through selection is treated as a recurring cognitive trap in the analysis of evaluability.
Why is Choice considered important across multiple disciplines?
Choice is foundational because it frames how beings evaluate, prioritize, and commit to actions, making it a core concern in decision theory, psychology, and economics alike. Its study reveals that the structure and quantity of available options shape not just the decision itself but the emotional and cognitive experience surrounding it.
More in Philosophical Traditions 1-24
Elsewhere in the Philosophical Traditions universe
Spotted an error? Know more?
This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record